Sacrificing the Delusion

Courtesy of Michael Baxter

Sustainably Talking

Michael Baxter was brave enough to invite me to share my radical ideas on a public platform. Any discussion like this is extremely helpful for both participants to share their perception on the human predicament. I would love for everyone to have the time and the opportunity to pitch into the collective conversation that is needed to reshape our civilisation into a direction that migh maximise mitigation from ecosystems collapse.

The full video is available on YouTube. I was grateful for the experience to express my opinions on the challenges that face humanity as ecosystems collapse escalates. The time in minutes and seconds is shown below if you are interested in listening to some highlights.

7:00 Deciding Whether to Have Children. Discussing the difficulty facing young adults when deciding whether to risk bringing a child into our collapsing world. Our young adults need our emotional support both ways, whether they decide to become parents or not. They do not need to be made to feel guilty about choosing not to have children. Nor do they deserve to have contraceptive or abortive healthcare withheld. We must provide as much help as possible for them to make fully informed choices, and to facilitate that choice, and the global village needs to come together to ensure every child receives subsistence and shelter. Rachel Donald’s article Should You Have Kids? is an excellent guide.

15:15 Pronatalist Peer Pressure. Huge peer pressure exists for a women deciding they do not want to bring children into ecosystems collapse. The Birth Strike movement collapsed in 2020 from the vindictive reception it received from mainstream media. JD Vance sneered at women choosing not to have children as ‘Cat Ladies’.

17:30 Catastrophe. Tipping points, the Black Swan concept by Nassim Nicholas Taleb. A mindset tipping point would be a good thing. Since the interview was recorded, Hans Stegeman has published an article describing his feelings flashback to the 2008 crisis.

20:10 Energy Transition and Doughnut Economics. 100 years of ecological debt means that we cannot simply step into sustainability by using Kate Raworth’s Doughnut model.

21:20 Ecological Debt versus Financial Debt. Money is just a tool for exchanging resources, a financial debt is a concept that we can erase if we choose. Ecological debt has existential qualities, like the mass extinction event and climate change. Jean Christophe Duval (Debunk’Onomy) is suggesting a monetary model (NEMO IMS) that could run alongside the debt-based model to facilitate the very long-term projects that offer ecological returns rather than monetary returns.

23:07 Efficiency. Confronting Jevon’s Paradox

24:00 Military Industrial Complex and the Financial Ponzi scheme. The many conomists who are pointing out the Ponzi Scheme qualities of the global financial system: e.g. Gary Stevenson and Prof Steve Keen

28:20 Global North/South. The total lack of wise leadership from the Global North means they have no right to criticise anyone else.

29:50 Our Fantasy World. Accepting the speed and scale of escalating ecosystems collapse is key to the mindset shift.

31:34 The Energy Transition. This just exacerbates the situation whilst we keep the mindset for economic growth and pronatalism.

33:55 Immigration (UK). Reference to the Das Gupta report: Economics of Biodiversity which clearly states that the UK is overpopulated. Discussions about immigration need to be framed in the context of man-made global and local ecosystems collapse to avoid drifting into the Machiavellian technique of finding a scapegoat to blame.

37:28 Valuing Natural Capital It is a huge challenge for business leaders to learn that Natural Capital is more valuable than money

39:16 Who needs to Sacrifice What? We all need to sacrifice the belief that we can fix the existential crisis. We also need to embrace the belief that we can achieve profound changes to our socio-economic cultures that would enable us to minimise consumption per capita and birth rates globally. We all need to give up the pretence and the delusion. We cannot afford the military industrial complex nor the wealth hierarchy in its current grotesque and growing proportions.

40:30 Climate Change Denial. This is just part of the same mass psychosis that enables us to pretend that the global finance system is not collapsing. Our prestigious universities are dedicated to maintaining the wealth hierarchy. There is no funding for researching how to implement Degrowth strategies, so they don’t go down that route, although it is quite obviously a prerequisite for sustainability.

43:21 Closing Words. Life could become very exciting for everyone if we just had the guts to admit growth economics is not working and begin to collaborate on peaceful downsizing.