Lili the Loser

Four Categories suggested by Cippola

The Stupids

According to Carlo Cippola, behavior that injures both yourself and others can be defined as ‘Stupid’. This article puts forward a case that most of our environmental organisations are currently operating in this category. My justification for this claim follows.

The Living Well Within Limits (LiLi) project is widely referenced as an aspirational model by those in the field of sustainability. The LiLi project models the minimum biophysical resources (like energy and materials) required to guarantee a decent standard of living for the global population while preventing warming from exceeding 1.5°C. There is nothing in this project that factors in the extra burden of air-conditioning as temperatures soar up into unbearable levels, nor the impact of escalating ecosystems collapse, nor the growing energy and ecological burden incurred by AI.

The LiLi project concluded in 2021; it assumes that 1.5 degrees of warming does not play out. Current data shows emissions have not dropped fast enough, making an overshoot of the 1.5°C limit very likely. There is recent research that estimates that previous models underestimated by 25%. The conclusion has enormous implications. For instance, a project called the Climate Action Tracker currently projects that average global surface temperatures will rise by 2.6°C above pre-industrial levels by 2100 if countries implement existing policies. This new research suggests that we are instead heading for 3.25°C even with successful policy implementation.

We are on a finite planet of 12 billion global hectares. We consume 20 billion global hectares per annum. We have been consuming more than 12 billion global hectares per annum for over 50 years. This is the definition of ecological overshoot. The carrying-capacity is about 6 billion global hectares, this allows space for biodiversity to flourish. The last time humans consumed less than 6 billion gha per annum was about 100 years ago. Consumption per capita was much less and population was about 2 or 3 billion. We have recent research that estimates a sustainable human population is around 2.5 billion, less than one third of current levels.

I know of no environmental organisation that is suggesting that we would be wise to shrink our global enterprise back within 6 billon global hectares consumption per annum. There is unanimous refusal to consider the obvious route to maximise mitigation from ecosystems collapse, namely encouraging minimal birth rates and minimal consumption per capita. This is an example of Stupid behaviour as defined by Cippola; we are harming ourselves and harming others by not even attempting to maximise mitigation from ecosystems collapse.

The Intelligents

According to Cippola the ‘Intelligents’ create win-win situations. Many people will be inclined to think that a successful entrepreneur will come into this bracket. An entrepreneur creates jobs so their employees will also benefit from his ingenuity, employees in a successful business can afford to buy houses and raise families. However, this is a thoroughly anthropocentric view. The extra houses for the staff and their children will all add to the total burden on Earth’s ecosystems. In ecological terms this type of ‘intelligent’ behavior has become extremely harmful to both employer and employee. This was not the case before we began to exceed Earth’s carrying capacity. This example demonstrates how behavior that was at one time beneficial can become harmful in a different context. In this way behavior that was once Intelligent by Cippola’s definition, can shift into the Stupid category through changing externalities.

Unfortunately, humans became habituated to admiring the wealthy and believing that they help us to ‘progress’. Wealthy people are assumed to be in the Intelligent category unless they are seen to be Bandits by directly harming other humans. The damage that they do to Earth’s ecosystems was always ignored. We have created huge ecological debts; not one environmental organisation admits that these debts need to be fully repaid before genuine sustainability can be achieved.

The Bandits

If we factor in the harm to our ecosystems, then we can see that any wealthy financial Bandits are harming themselves as well as the victims of their malicious actions; for they will have a high ecological footprint due to their wealth. Therefore in the current context, many Bandits have also moved into the Stupid category.

As for the Bandits inflicting physical harm, examples like Israel and the USA are inflicting huge ecological damage in their attempts to rule the world. Thus these Bandits are also relocating into the Stupid category.

The Helpless

The Helpless probably needs to include people like me, living in torment and anguish. I spend my time saying ‘We are in trouble, we are harming ourselves’ please stop. Those who believe that they are Intelligents, or Bandits work to silence people like me. They assume that because I am in the minority I must be wrong. They have not yet spotted the shifting reality that recategorised their behaviors into the Stupid quadrant.

Conclusion

This article is dedicated to Kasper Benjamin Reimer Bjørkskov. Kasper has great faith in the LiLi project and rejects the idea of teaching eco-aware family planning. A special thank you to the Fair Start Movement for all your work tackling the illegal baselining that underpins most of our modern techno-industrial civilization.